SFGov Watch

1. Federal Collaboration and Sanctuary City Policies
   1. Evaluating Federal Partnerships
   2. Historical Context and Action Plan
2. Weekly Crime Trends
   1. Crime Reductions and Safety Successes
   2. High-Profile Incidents
3. Policy Updates and Emerging Issues
   1. Addressing “Swatting”
   2. Sparks Reports and Policy Revisions
4. Community Engagement and Public Comment
   1. Huckleberry Youth Programs and DGO 7.01 Revisions
   2. Honoring Victims and Supporting Families
5. Other Topics

Federal Collaboration and Sanctuary City Policies

Evaluating Federal Partnerships

A key discussion focused on San Francisco Police Department’s (SFPD) partnerships with federal agencies. Commissioners expressed concerns about potential conflicts between federal policies and San Francisco’s sanctuary city principles, particularly in light of a possible shift in federal administration.

The Commission requested a detailed report on current federal collaborations, their operational and financial implications, and the feasibility of terminating partnerships if conflicts arise. This topic gained attention because it underscores the city’s commitment to protecting immigrant communities while balancing public safety needs.

Historical Context and Action Plan

In 2016, similar partnerships were halted due to their incompatibility with local values. Commissioners emphasized learning from these precedents to proactively address challenges. The requested report will help determine which partnerships may need reevaluation, ensuring the city remains aligned with its progressive policies.

Weekly Crime Trends

Crime Reductions and Safety Successes

Assistant Chief David Lazar presented encouraging statistics: overall crime is down 30% year-to-date, with significant reductions in gun violence (26%) and homicides (34%). These historic lows were attributed to collaborative initiatives, targeted enforcement, and innovative crime prevention strategies.

High-Profile Incidents

Several specific cases were highlighted:

• A pregnant woman shot in District 10, with both mother and fetus surviving, underscoring the ongoing dangers of gun violence despite overall reductions.
• A surge in commercial burglaries involving vehicles, prompting discussions on enhanced overnight patrol strategies.
• A Tenderloin operation that seized over 800 grams of narcotics, showcasing the effectiveness of multi-agency collaborations.

The report sparked discussions on how to sustain these successes and address persistent challenges like organized retail theft.

Policy Updates and Emerging Issues

Addressing “Swatting”

A standout discussion focused on “swatting” incidents—false 911 calls intended to provoke an armed police response. The Commission acknowledged a lack of existing guidelines within SFPD and committed to developing new policies to address this emerging threat. This proactive approach reflects San Francisco’s dedication to community safety and trust.

Sparks Reports and Policy Revisions

The Commission reviewed the Q3 2024 Sparks Reports, which highlighted progress on various policy updates. Notable advancements included revisions to outdated general orders and collaborative efforts on sensitive topics like sexual assault procedures. These discussions reinforced the importance of maintaining a dynamic and responsive policy framework.

Community Engagement and Public Comment

Huckleberry Youth Programs and DGO 7.01 Revisions

Public commenters, including representatives from Huckleberry Youth Programs, emphasized the need for updated policies guiding officer interactions with youth. These revisions aim to foster equitable treatment and better outcomes for young people in the field. Commissioners expressed support, acknowledging the value of community input in shaping effective policies.

Honoring Victims and Supporting Families

A parent spoke about their long fight to honor their son’s memory through a street renaming initiative. This heartfelt moment underscored the Commission’s role in addressing both policy-level and deeply personal community concerns.

Other Topics

• Officer Recognition: Officer Cristina Cistaro was honored for exceptional service at Taraval Station.
• Tenderloin Drug Enforcement: Between November 3 and 17, 54 arrests were made, and significant quantities of narcotics were seized.
• Neglect-of-Duty Allegations: The Department of Police Accountability (DPA) reported neglect-of-duty as the most common complaint, with failures in investigations and property handling topping the list.
• DPA Audit Progress: The DPA’s recent audit was sent to SFPD for review, with a final report expected in January.
• Vehicle Pursuit Policy Training: The Commission discussed integrating DOJ-recommended training modules into SFPD’s ongoing education efforts.