Board of Supervisors: Dec 3, 2024

The Board of Supervisors discussed a lawsuit settlement related to a transgender income program, approved significant funding for infrastructure and housing projects, advanced ordinances on surveillance and AI transparency, and addressed mental health and homelessness policies, while also honoring key public figures and leaders in city services.

Settlement Over Transgender Income Program Sparks Debate

Supervisor Preston Opposes Settlement

One of the most contentious discussions during the Board of Supervisors meeting revolved around the settlement of a lawsuit concerning the city’s guaranteed income program for low-income transgender residents. Supervisor Dean Preston argued vehemently against the settlement, warning that agreeing to an injunction could restrict the city’s ability to launch similar programs in the future. He stressed that the courts should make rulings, rather than the city preemptively conceding, to avoid undermining support for vulnerable communities.

Supervisor Ronen Defends Settlement

In contrast, Supervisor Hillary Ronen supported the settlement, citing flaws in how the original program was structured. While reaffirming her commitment to the transgender community, she expressed concerns about the financial and legal risks of continuing the litigation. Ronen emphasized that future programs must be designed to withstand legal challenges and achieve their goals effectively.

Major Bond Allocations for Infrastructure and Housing

Funding Key Projects

The Board approved over $571 million in general obligation bonds for various critical projects, including affordable housing, flood resilience, and emergency response infrastructure. These funds will be used for projects like the development of affordable housing units, improvements to the city’s firefighting water systems, and planning for Embarcadero flood defenses. Supervisors highlighted how these initiatives aim to address long-standing issues in safety, housing, and infrastructure resilience.

Public Safety and Housing Focus

A portion of the funds will also go to the Department of Public Works and the Public Utilities Commission to bolster emergency response capabilities. This includes improving police and fire facilities and supporting low- and middle-income housing initiatives. The discussion underscored the city’s priorities in creating safer communities and alleviating the housing crisis.

Mental Health SF: Ensuring Housing for the Vulnerable

Rapid Rehousing Ordinance

The Board discussed an ordinance requiring the city to assess households exiting homelessness and provide up to five years of rapid rehousing support if deemed necessary to prevent returns to homelessness. Supervisors praised the initiative as a proactive approach to stabilizing vulnerable households while calling for thorough reporting and accountability measures.

Transparency in Surveillance and AI Use

Updating Surveillance Ordinance

The Board passed amendments to the city’s surveillance ordinance to reduce administrative burdens while enhancing reporting requirements. These changes aim to streamline the process while ensuring proper oversight of surveillance technologies used by city departments.

AI Inventory for Public Accountability

The Board also approved the creation of a public inventory of artificial intelligence tools used by city departments. Supervisor Ronen championed the measure, emphasizing the need for transparency and accountability as the city increasingly incorporates AI into its operations.

Tribute to Jesse Smith, Retiring Chief Assistant City Attorney

Honoring Decades of Service

Jesse Smith, the retiring Chief Assistant City Attorney, received an emotional tribute from supervisors and colleagues. Supervisors lauded Smith’s significant contributions to major city projects, such as Mission Bay and the Warriors Arena, and his leadership during legal battles with the Trump administration. Former City Attorneys and current staff highlighted his integrity, mentorship, and dedication to public service.

SFGov Watch